HISTORY OF UKRAINE OF THE 19TH CENTURY: CONTENT LINES OF MODERN RESEARCH

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.33402/up.2021-14-45-66

Keywords:

«long» 19th century, formation of the Ukrainian modern nation, modernization, cultural and intellectual history of Ukraine of the 19th century, modern historiography

Abstract

The article highlights the main controversial issues of modern historiography, which relate to the study of the history of Ukraine’s «long» 19th century. The concepts of the authors of generalizing works and the changes made in them during the last two decades are analyzed.It is claimed that the historiography of this historical period in Ukraine developed through the accumulation of new research topics, and conceptual rethinking took place under the infl uence of Western historiography. This allowed the authors to move away from the subordination of the material to a predetermined scheme of nation-building (or national revival) and to consider the historical process as a complex interaction of various factors. Modern historians move away from a simplistic understanding of the collective identities of the time and recognize their multiplicity, the connection with the concept of loyalty, the transition from one to another and the possibility of a comfortable combination or multiple situational changes in one lifetime. Among the main issues that Ukrainian historians continue to discuss in the «long nineteenth century» are: the formation of imaginary and real space of modern Ukraine, the criteria for periodization of this historical time, the relationship between tradition and modernization and the impact of modernization and urbanization on national movements, the relationship between the «new imperial history» and the concepts of modern nations, issues of cultural and intellectual history (history of ideas) and the possibilities and features of studying the history of the nineteenth century through «history from below», attention to the personal experience of a particular person. The ways of forming stereotypical notions due to excessive abuse of «retrospective history» are shown, which pushes researchers to make evaluative judgments about the events and phenomena of the 19th century, based on the experience of the 20th century. Methods of research and presentation of multiculturalism and interaction of diff erent cultures on the ethnic border are discussed. It is shown that due to signifi cant transformations of everyday life of the 19th century can be represented as «time of change». It is argued that the immediate prospects in the study of the history of Ukraine «long» 19th century. are to read and re-read sources that represent diff erent points of view and ways of experiencing the same processes and phenomena.

References

Adadurov, V., & Sklokin, V. (Eds.). (2020). Imperski identychnosti v ukrainskii istorii XVIII – pershoi polovyny XIX st. Lviv: Vyd-vo UKU [in Ukrainian].

Arkusha, O. H., Kondratiuk, K. K., Mudryi, M. M., & Sukhyi, O. M. (2016). Chas narodiv. Istoriia Ukrainy XIX stolittia: navch. posib. (M. M. Mudryi, Ed.). Lviv: LNU im. I. Franka [in Ukrainian].

Berk, P. (2010). Istoriia podii i vidrodzhennia naratyvu. Novi pidkhody do istoriopysannia. Kyiv: Nika-Tsentr [in Ukrainian].

Betlii, O., Dysa, K., & Martyniuk, O. (Comps.). (2016). Zhyvuchy v modernomu misti: Kyiv kintsia XIX – seredyny XX stolit. Kyiv: Dukh i Litera [in Ukrainian].

Chornovol, I. (2015). Komparatyvni frontyry. Svitovyi i vitchyznianyi vymir. Kyiv: Krytyka [in Ukrainian].

Chornyi, D. (2007). Po livyi bik Dnipra: problemy modernizatsii mist Ukrainy (kinets XIX– pochatok XX st.). Kharkiv: KhNU im. V. N. Karazina [in Ukrainian].

Dashkevych, Ya. (2011). Skhidna Halychyna: etnichni vidnosyny, natsionalni mify ta mentalitety. In Ya. Dashkevych, «…Uchy nelozhnymy ustamy kazaty pravdu». Istorychna eseistyka (1989–2008) (p. 593). Kyiv: Tempora [in Ukrainian].

Doich, K. (2006). Narody, natsii ta komunikatsiia. In O. Protsenko, V. Lisovyi (Comps.), Natsionalizm. Teorii natsii ta natsionalizmu vid Yohana Fikhte do Ernesta Gelnera. Antolohiia (pp. 317–332). Kyiv: Smoloskyp [in Ukrainian].

Hagen, von M. (1995). Does Ukraine Have a History? Slavic Review, 54 (3), 658–673 [in English].

Hroch, M. (2020). Powstanie małych narodów w Europie Środkowej i Południowo- Wschodniej. Warsaw: Studium Europy Wschodniej Uniwersytetu Warszawskiego [in Polish].

Hrushevskyi, M. (1927). Perednie slovo. In Za sto lit. Materialy z hromadskoho i literaturnoho zhyttia Ukrainy XIX i pochatkiv XX st. (Vol. 1, pp. 4–5). Kyiv: Derzhvydav Ukrainy [in Ukrainian].

Hrytsak, Ya. (2006). Prorok u svoii vitchyzni. Franko ta yoho spilnota (1856–1886). Kyiv: Krytyka [in Ukrainian].

Hrytsak, Ya. (2019). Narys istorii Ukrainy. Formuvannia modernoi natsii XIX–XX stolittia. Kyiv: Yakaboo publishing [in Ukrainian].

Kasianov, H. (2004). «Piknik na obochine»: osmysleniie imperskoho proshloho v sovremennoi ukrainskoi istoriografi i. Novaia imperskaia istoriia postsovetskoho prostrans- tva (Y. Gerasymov, Ed.). Kazan: Tsentr issledovanii natsyonalizma i imperii [in Russian].

Khymka, Dzh.-P. (2002). Zarodzhennia polskoi sotsial-demokratii ta ukrainskoho radykalizmu v Halychyni (1860–1890). Kyiv: Osnovni tsinnosti [in Ukrainian].

Konstantinova, V. (2010). Urbanizatsiia: pivdennoukrainskyi vymir (1861–1904 roky). Zaporizhzhia: AA Tandem [in Ukrainian].

Kravchenko, B. (1997). Sotsialni zminy i natsionalna svidomist v Ukraini XX stolittia (V. Ivashko, V. Korniienko, Trans.). Kyiv: Osnovy [in Ukrainian].

Kravchenko, V. (2011). Ukraina, imperiia, Rosiia. Ohliad suchasnoi istoriohrafi i. In V. Kravchenko (Ed.), Ukraina, imperiia, Rosiia. Vybrani statti z modernoi istorii ta istoriohrafi i (pp. 391–454). Kyiv: Krytyka [in Ukrainian].

Kutsmani, B. (2019). Brody. Prykordonne halytske misto v dovhomu XIX stolitti (V. Kamianets, Trans.). Lviv: Litopys [in Ukrainian].

Lysiak-Rudnytskyi, I. (1994). Struktura ukrainskoi istorii v XIX stolitti. In I. Lysiak- Rudnytskyi, Istorychni ese (Vol. 1, pp. 193–202). Kyiv: Osnovy [in Ukrainian].

Magocsi, P. R. (1989). The Ukrainian National Revival: A New Analitacal Framework. Canadian Rewiew of Studies in Nationalism, 16, 45–62 [in Russian].

Masliichuk, V. (2007). Provintsiia na perekhresti kultur. Doslidzhennia z istorii Slobidskoi Ukrainy XVII–XIX st. Kharkiv: Kharkivskyi pryvatnyi muzei miskoi sadyby [in Ukrainian].

Ohloblyn, O. (1971). Problema skhemy istorii Ukrainy 19–20 stolittia (do 1917 roku). Ukrainskyi istoryk, 1–2 (29–30), 5-9 [in Ukrainian].

Plokhii, S. (2013). Kozatskyi mif. Istoriia ta natsiietvorennia v epokhu imperii. Kyiv: Laurus [in Ukrainian].

Plokhii, S. (2016). Brama Yevropy. Istoriia Ukrainy vid skifskykh voien do nezalezhnosti. Kharkiv: KSD [in Ukrainian].

Pritsak, O. Y. (2015). Shcho take istoriia Ukrainy? Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal, 1, 177–210 [in Ukrainian].

Reient, O. P. (2007). Istoriia Ukrainy XIX – pochatku XX st.: metodolohichnyi zriz i tematychni napriamy naukovoho poshuku. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal, 6, 218–232 [in Ukrainian].

Reient, O. P. (2011). Ukrainske XIX stolittia: suchasni problemy doslidzhennia. Problemy istorii Ukrainy XIX – pochatku XX st., 19, 6–26 [in Ukrainian].

Reient, O. P. (2016). Ukraina v impersku dobu (XIX – pochatok XX stolittia). Kyiv: Arii [in Ukrainian].

Reient, O. P. (Ed.). (2019). Vid muriv do bulvariv: tvorennia modernoho mista v Ukraini (kinets XVIII – pochatok XX st.). Kyiv: Instytut istorii Ukrainy NANU [in Ukrainian].

Sarbei, V. H. (1999). Natsionalne vidrodzhennia Ukrainy. Ukraina kriz viky (Vol. 9). Kyiv: Vydavnychyi dim «Alternatyvy» [in Ukrainian].

Shandra, V. S. (2005). Heneral-hubernatorstva v Ukraini. XIX – pochatok XX st. Kyiv: Instytut istorii Ukrainy NANU [in Ukrainian].

Shporliuk, R. (2016). Formuvannia modernykh natsii: Ukraina – Rosiia – Polshcha. Kyiv: Dukh i litera [in Ukrainian].

Tsveih, S. (2019). Svit uchora. Spohady yevropeitsia (A. V. Savchenko, Trans.). Kharkiv: Folio [in Ukrainian].

Vermenych, Ya. (2011). Istorychna urbanistyka v Ukraini: teoriia mistoznavstva i metodyka litochyslennia. Kyiv: Instytut istorii Ukrainy NANU [in Ukrainian].

Vulf, L. (2009). Vynaidennia Skhidnoi Yevropy. Mapa tsyvilizatsii u svidomosti epokhy Prosvitnytstva. Kyiv: Krytyka [in Ukrainian].

Yekelchyk, S. (2011). Istoriia Ukrainy. Stanovlennia modernoi natsii. Kyiv: Laurus [in Ukrainian].

Published

2025-05-23